Examiner's Notes
You assessed this answer as Grade 6.
Hover over the highlighted text to read the examiner’s comments.
Question: Read from: ‘“Let me be rightly understood”’ to ‘“if your nephew does not object to them, they can be nothing to you”’ (Vol. 3, Ch. 14). In this extract, Lady Catherine states her objections to Elizabeth marrying Darcy.
Starting with this extract, explore how Austen presents the relationships between Lady Catherine and Elizabeth.
Write about:
- how Austen presents Lady Catherine’s feelings in this extract
- how Austen presents the relationship between Lady Catherine and Elizabeth in the novel as a whole.
The way she speaks shows that she thinks she is in charge of the situation. ‘Let me be rightly understood’ is a very strong statement and makes it sound like a teacher telling off a little child but of course Lizzie is not a child, but a grown woman.
Another thing is that she speaks in a very rude way and says nasty things about Elizabeth. For example, she says, ‘of inferior birth, of no importance in the world, and wholly unallied to the family.’ By saying she is not important she is making it sound as if Elizabeth is a nobody and that Lady Catherine is like the lady of the manor. This is not a respectful way to talk to anyone let alone someone who is basically a nice person.
But Lady Catherine won’t give up. She is very determined and very unhappy that this young woman is standing up to her. But most important of all she threatens her. ‘Your alliance will be a disgrace; your name will never even be mentioned by any of us.’
This basically means that if they get married then they not be talked about by any of the rich landowners and the family. So she is saying that they will be embarrassed and shamed by him marrying a common girl. This is not unusual as this is how the rich viewed things in Austen’s day.
Elizabeth has met Lady Catherine before when she was staying with Charlotte. They didn’t get on very well then because Elizabeth didn’t want to tell Lady Catherine how old she was and Lady Catherine didn’t like not getting an answer. She is used to people flattering her and doing everything she says because she is rich and powerful. Elizabeth just thinks she is nosy. ‘Elizabeth felt all the impertinence of her questions, but answered them very composedly. That suggests that Elizabeth was trying to be polite.
Mr Darcy was also staying at Rosings when Elizabeth was there. She expected him to be as snobbish as his aunt and in those days he was. By the time Lady Catherine comes to Longbourn to tell Elizabeth not to marry Darcy, Elizabeth has met him again at Pemberley and she has seen him being polite to her aunt and uncle. So now she can say ‘if your nephew does not object to them they can be nothing to you’ but she doesn’t really know. When Lady Catherine has gone she can’t talk to anyone about the conversation because she doesn’t know what to think. She knows that she loves Darcy but she doesn’t know whether he will listen to his aunt or what Lady Catherine will do next.